Roman Historians
The Evolution of Historical Writing from Epic Poetry to Prose Chronicles
The development of Roman historiography reflects a fascinating journey from its origins in Greek influences to the establishment of a distinct Roman tradition. This evolution moved from epic poetry inspired by mythology to more structured prose chronicles that aimed to document political, military, and societal developments. Roman historians played a crucial role in shaping the historical narrative of the Roman Empire, weaving together myth, reality, and politics to create a comprehensive record of Rome's rise and its internal and external struggles. Major figures like Polybius, Livy, Tacitus, and Suetonius helped establish the foundations of historical writing, blending narrative style with detailed analysis and interpretation.
Fresco found in Pompeii depicting a scene related to the Trojan War, with Helen and Paris - Pompeii, Regio IX, 7, 5.
Helen is the beautiful bride of Menelaus, king of Sparta, in whom Paris falls in love. He takes it with him to Troy, thus causing the war between the Greeks and Trojans. The story of the founding of Rome begins with Aeneas, a Trojan hero who, after the end of the Trojan War, managed to escape with few followers.
Early Influences and the Greek Legacy
In the mid-fifth century BCE, Herodotus, often referred to as the "Father of History," settled in the Athenian colony of Thurii in southern Italy. At that time, Rome had not yet consolidated its power in the Italian peninsula and was still grappling with forces like the Etruscans and the Gauls, who sacked Rome in 390 BCE. Though Herodotus's work laid the groundwork for historical inquiry, the early Roman historians did not directly emulate his style, which emphasized geography and ethnography.
Instead, the initial phase of Roman historiography was influenced by Greek cultural and literary traditions, but with a stronger focus on political and military themes. Polybius, a Greek historian who lived in Rome during the 2nd century BCE, was a significant figure in this period. He viewed Rome's power as stemming from its political institutions, particularly its constitution. His historical approach was influenced by Aristotelian political theory and Thucydides' emphasis on empirical research, encouraging the use of archival sources—an approach that would shape later Roman historiography.
The Transition from Epic Poetry to Prose
Roman historiography initially mirrored the Greek tradition through epic poetry, with writers like Gnaeus Naevius and Quintus Ennius drawing on mythological tales to trace Rome's origins back to Aeneas, a legendary Trojan prince. Although they were Roman citizens, these early poets often wrote in Greek, underscoring the profound influence of Greek culture on Roman literature. These works mixed myth with historical facts, serving as a bridge between oral traditions and the emerging historical narrative.
The first significant shift towards prose in Roman historiography came with Q. Fabius Pictor, who wrote in Greek, and Marcus Porcius Cato (Cato the Elder), who broke new ground by writing in Latin. Cato's work, written in a more straightforward and moralistic tone, marked the beginning of Latin prose history, emphasizing patriotism and moral integrity. His focus on the values of Roman society became a defining feature of later Roman historians.
The Role of Annalists and the Development of Historical Writing
The annalists were pivotal in shaping Roman historical writing. They documented yearly events, listing political occurrences and the names of magistrates in a factual manner. Unlike their Greek counterparts, who often included interpretation and narrative style, Roman annalists like L. Coelius Antipater, Valerius Antias, and Q. Claudius Quadrigarius focused primarily on recording data without much analysis. Despite this, their works were invaluable resources for later historians like Livy, who sought to create more coherent and interpretative narratives.
M. Terentius Varro, a contemporary of these annalists, introduced a more analytical approach to cultural and historical studies, blending literature with history. He was followed by Sallust, a former military general, whose writings linked Rome's decline to moral decay, creating a narrative that was both historical and moralistic. Sallust's work suggested that Rome's internal failures were as significant as any external threats, laying the groundwork for the later theme of Rome's inevitable fall.
Livy: Myth and Reality in Roman History
Livy (Titus Livius) stands out as one of Rome's most prolific historians, best known for his monumental work "Ab Urbe Condita" (From the Founding of the City), which originally consisted of 142 books, though only 35 have survived. Unlike earlier Roman historians, Livy was not involved in politics, which allowed him to devote himself entirely to writing. His work synthesized myths, legends, and factual accounts, creating a detailed narrative of Rome’s history from its legendary beginnings to its emergence as a dominant power.
Livy’s inclusion of myths and supernatural events, such as auguries and omens, was influenced by the widespread belief in the divine's role in human affairs, a common theme in Stoic philosophy, which Livy partially adhered to. He was careful to document these occurrences because they were integral to understanding Roman culture and decision-making processes, even if he personally remained skeptical of their significance. Livy's ability to blend historical accuracy with storytelling made him both a respected historian and a literary figure.
Tacitus: Analyzing Power and Corruption
Publius Cornelius Tacitus was a masterful historian whose works like "Germania" and the "Annals" offered a critical analysis of Roman society, politics, and the empire’s governance. His writings on the Germanic tribes provided insight into the societies that would eventually play a crucial role in the fall of the Roman Empire. Tacitus's focus on the chaos and corruption during the reigns of Roman emperors in his works "Historiae" and "Annals" is renowned for its psychological depth and moral critique.
Tacitus emphasized the flaws within the Roman political system and the moral decay among the ruling classes. His portrayal of Rome was less idealized compared to his predecessors, as he sought to reveal the underlying causes of the empire's instability. Tacitus's sophisticated narrative style and dedication to using archival research set new standards for historical writing and influenced future historians.
Suetonius: The Lives Behind the Power
Gaius Suetonius Tranquillus, another significant figure in Roman historiography, was known for his biographical approach. His most famous work, "Lives of the Caesars," provides detailed accounts of the lives of Roman emperors from Julius Caesar to Nero. Suetonius's method differed from the traditional historical narratives, focusing instead on the personalities, private lives, and scandals of these rulers. While some critics viewed his style as sensationalist, his keen eye for detail and inclusion of source materials in their original languages make his work a valuable resource for understanding the complexities of Roman leadership.
Suetonius's biographical style has sometimes been dismissed as tabloid-like, yet his writings reveal much about the cultural and political dynamics of the time. His work captures the human aspects of Rome’s leaders, emphasizing the impact of individual personalities on the course of Roman history.
Last update: October 18, 2024
DONATE Go to definitions: A | B | C | D | E | F | G | H | I | J | K | L | M | N | O | P | Q | R | S | T | U | V | W | X | Y | Z
See also: